- Additional devices that each act on their own. Add the user’s laptop passkey alongside their phone passkey. Either device can sign a transfer. This is what most consumer apps want.
- Co-signing where multiple signers must approve. Require two signatures (or three of four, etc.) before any transfer goes through. This is what agent treasuries, shared wallets, and high-value accounts want.
Available without advertisement until external audit closes.
When to use which
Concrete examples in production today:
- Agent treasuries — an automated agent spends up to $X/day on its own, anything bigger requires a co-sign from the user’s passkey. 2-of-2 above the threshold, 1-of-2 below.
- AI-API service accounts — a service account shares custody with a human operator. Routine API spend doesn’t prompt; settlement transfers do.
- Co-signed org treasuries — Chipi credits balance is N-of-M with key roles distributed across finance + ops + the founder.
Compared to single-owner
Single-owner SHHH wallets sign via one V2_SNIP12 envelope:V2_SNIP12 tag, which the outer tag replaces:
buildThresholdEnvelope takes the per-kind builders’ envelopes as they are and drops the tags (14.17.0+; earlier versions kept them, and the contract rejected those envelopes with THRESH: bad owner_id).
Each inner envelope can be a different signer kind. The wallet validates each inner envelope against its registered verifier class, rejects a repeated owner, sums the verified owners’ weights, and admits the call only when that sum reaches the threshold. The threshold is not in the envelope: the set of owners, their weights and the threshold live on-chain.
On V8.5 the single-owner envelope is held to the same rule: an owner whose weight is below the threshold gets SHHH: below threshold, with one exception, a lone cancel_recovery naming that owner (the recovery veto). An owner whose weight alone meets the threshold can still sign alone. One consequence for multisig coordinators: on V8.4 each collected approval is by itself a valid single-owner signature for the same transaction, so treat stored approvals for V8.4 wallets as executable.
Owner kinds within a threshold
Anything that works as a single-owner signer kind works as a threshold owner. You can mix:- An EOA on MetaMask (
EIP191_SECP256K1) co-signs with a passkey (WEBAUTHN_P256) - A Phantom / Solana wallet (
ED25519) co-signs with a STARK key held server-side - A JWT_ES256 service account co-signs with a STARK key held server-side
- A Starknet wallet the user already has, such as Bramble (
STARK_SNIP12), co-signs with a passkey. Bramble signs withwallet_signTypedDataandbuildStarkSnip12Envelopewraps its signature into an inner envelope. See Trusted wallets - A guardian (
role: "GUARDIAN") does NOT count toward the threshold for normal transactions — guardians only initiate recovery, never co-sign
propose_add_verifier_class (48h) and execute it before execute_add_owner. See New signer kinds.
Configuring N and M
The wallet is created with N initial owners (M=N at start). Add or remove owners post-creation via the recovery flows in recovery:propose_add_owner→execute_add_ownerafter 48hpropose_remove_owner→execute_remove_ownerafter 24hpropose_set_threshold→execute_set_thresholdafter 48h (above 1 only on V8.5+)propose_add_verifier_class→execute_add_verifier_classafter 48h, for a signer kind the wallet doesn’t verify yet
cancel_pending_op. On a V8.5 wallet with threshold 2+, every one of these calls, cancels included, needs the threshold too: one owner alone can only cancel a recovery.
SDK status
External wallets that don’t expose a key (MetaMask, Phantom, Bramble)
MetaMask, Phantom and Bramble never hand you a private key — the user signs in their wallet and you get a signature back. Each has a builder that wraps that signature into an inner envelope:
Bramble signs typed data, never a raw hash: have it sign
starkSnip12ApprovalTypedData({ walletAddress, messageHash: oeHash }) with
wallet_signTypedData, then pass the result as returned to
buildStarkSnip12Envelope({ signature, ownerIndex }).
For Phantom, the wallet must sign the exact bytes returned by
ed25519SignedBytes(messageHash) — the 64-byte hex-ASCII encoding of the OE
hash — not the raw 32-byte hash. The on-chain verifier reconstructs those same
bytes, so signing anything else fails verification.
Gas
The paymaster sums the per-kind gas overhead across each inner envelope. A 2-of-2 STARK + EIP-191 OE budgets 2M + 10M = 12M l2_gas for verification on top of the call’s own cost. See the passkey API reference for the kinds available client-side; gas tables live with the backend builders. This composes — you don’t budget gas yourself. The paymaster reserves it automatically based on the envelope shape.Threshold + recovery together
The headline product story for SHHH (V8.5+) is threshold combined with guardian recovery:- Day-to-day operations require N-of-M signatures
- Lost-key recovery still works because a guardian can initiate
initiate_recoveryeven if N-1 owners have lost their keys - Any one owner can still stop a recovery with
cancel_recoverynaming itself, even below the threshold
propose_remove_owner, 24h each).
Related
- Passkey reference — what each owner can be on the browser side
- Recovery — add/remove owners + guardian recovery
- Migration — getting from CHIPI v29 to SHHH first
